Love the coat!! Decent colour aswell. The crest on the sleeve sets it off a treat! Definately a Winner!!
Not a fan of the polo (by the way harry, you notice it has a longer back aswell!)
As for HL or P&S. I personally don't think they can be compared that much as one is far more expensive than the other.
I agree with CJ in that I haven't worn or looked at HL for ages! Last time was probably a t-shirt when I was about 13/14 so 11/12 years ago. If I'm being honest I think HL has a bit of a chavy reputation.

That coat is changing my mind a little.